Wednesday, March 29th, 2023

www.iwantmydisability.com

Nassau: 366 North Broadway Suite 410 Jericho, NY 11753
Suffolk: 445 Broad Hollow Road Suite 25 Melville, NY 11747
Call Us Toll-Free: (888) 572-0861 Email: jd@iwantmydisability.com

Friday, March 27th, 2009

Oops, CIGNA’s Done It Again

Yet another court has found that CIGNA’s terminating long term disability (“LTD”) benefits was so patently without merit that interest and attorney’s fees were awarded. CIGNA’s wrongful LTD termination and denials have become so rampant that ABC News’ Good Morning America did an expose on it. http://abcnews.go.com/Video/playerIndex?id=4724275

The facts of Gordon v. Northwest Airlines, Inc. Long-Term Disability Income Plan, which was decided a couple of weeks ago, mirror those of Alfano v. CIGNA Life Ins. Co. of New York, the case that I won a couple of months earlier. Gordon highlighted that this was not the first case where CIGNA mischaracterized medical records and erroneously asserted that a claimant’s doctor supported the claimant’s ability to sedentary work. Gordon is yet another example of CIGNA’s history of biased claims administration that, under the Supreme Court’s Metlife v. Glenn decision, requires ruling in favor of LTD claimants in closer cases.

In both Alfano and Gordon, CIGNA asked the treating doctors to complete a Physical Abilities Assessment (“PAA”), and each doctor concluded the claimant was limited to sitting less than 2.5 hours during an 8 hour day. Gordon declared that CIGNA’s conclusion that the PAA showed Gordon could do sedentary work was “manifestly false” and based “on an obvious misinterpretation,” and “simply mischaracterized” the PAA. Gordon explained that “Common sense dictates that that someone who cannot walk, sit, or stand more than 2.5 hours per day cannot do sedentary work.”

Similarly, in both Alfano and Gordon, CIGNA terminated LTD benefits based upon transferable skill analysis (“TSA”) that was based on the PAA. Gordon held that “the TSA does not explain how Gordon can do sedentary or light-duty work if he is limited to occasional sitting, standing and walking.”

Gordon ruled the claimant was entitled to interest and attorney fees because CIGNA’s “behavior toward Gordon in this case was not that of a fiduciary acting in his interests and the interests of plan participants. Rather, [CIGNA] acted like a company that first decided to deny Gordon’s claim and then went looking for evidence to justify that decision. CIGNA “egregiously mischaracterized the PAA, both internally and to Gordon, to support its conclusion that Gordon could do sedentary work.” Moreover, Gordon found that the CIGNA’s medical review “were so cursory as to amount to mere rubber stamping.” Once again, those are the same allegations that the claimant made in Alfano that the court accepted.

CIGNA was required to pay attorney fees because, “The evidence in the record is overwhelming that Gordon is incapable of earning a living. Rather than view the record through the eyes of a fiduciary, [CIGNA] bent over backwards to find an excuse-any excuse-to deny benefits to Gordon.” Gordon is yet another example that illustrates CIGNA’s practice and pattern of knowingly and wrongfully terminating LTD benefits. The Court awarded attorney’s fees because it held that by relying on the PAA and TSA to conclude that Gordon could work, CIGNA “acted not as a fiduciary, but as an adversary.”

Previous Next

2023 (5)

DDS Laziness

DDS Sham

2022 (46)

Is SSD Permanent? No.

Yao Syndrome

2021 (44)

The Wait is Over

Responsiveness Counts

2020 (47)

Judging Disabilities

2019 (44)

COLA

Social Media and Disability

2018 (55)

The Future of Social Security

2017 (50)

Witness Testimony

2016 (44)

NYSLERS Approval

2015 (50)

Sun Life Reverses Denial

Prudential Settles LTD Claim

2014 (60)

SSD Benefits for Hearing Loss

2013 (84)

2012 (87)

2011 (89)

2010 (75)

2009 (60)

2008 (70)

2007 (58)

DISCLAIMER
This website provides general information on disability law topics as a public service. Information is intended to be as accurate and current as possible, but should not be relied on as legal advice. No attorney/client relationship is created by viewing or using the content on this website. Each legal problem is different, and past performance does not guarantee future results. You should not act on any of the information contained in this site without first consulting legal counsel, which is why readers are advised to seek experienced legal representation in connection with disability related issues. Our Internet links are not associated with us, and we do not guarantee the accuracy of, any information contained in any link. Past performance doesn’t guarantee future results.

www.iwantmydisability.com

cc

Contact Us

Practice Areas

Social Security Disability

Disability Insurance Policies

Long Term Disability Plans

Union Disability Pension

NYS and NYC Disability Retirement

Federal Disability Retirement

Free Phone Consultation

Free Phone Consultation

Oops, CIGNA’s Done It Again